You don’t need me to tell you that we are living through troubled and troubling times. Where to begin? There’s Covid 19. There’s the ripple effects of Covid 19 -- a tanked economy leading to near record unemployment and social isolation leading to depression and aimlessness. There’s the police brutality against George Floyd. There is, both connected and unconnected to this, widespread lawlessness, violence, and destruction. I don’t remember feeling more disturbed by the times. But for me personally at least, there’s something else going on that’s every bit as disturbing.
Daniel Patrick Moynihan once said that everyone is entitled to his own opinion. That sounds about right. We share similar values – We want to be decent and upright people who make a positive impact in life. We love our families and want to provide for them as best we can. We want to be good citizens who help to conform our nation to its ideals.
But at the same time, we all come from different walks in life. We all have different priorities. We all have different personalities. So, although we share similar values, we differ as to how to give expression to them. We have different opinions -- to which, Moynihan asserts, we are entitled.
At one time, we took this as axiomatic. Not anymore. If you voice the “wrong” opinion, an amorphous squad of enforcers, let’s call them the Opinion Police – rise and retaliate. You are shamed on social media. You receive death threats. You are fired from your job.
We have a general sense of what opinions will land us in hot water, but at the same time it’s a minefield out there. The Opinion Police, coming at it from every angle, are always finding new opinions that don’t make their grade. It's the new McCarthyism, only this time not targeting Communists, but those who support freedom of thought and speech.
I guess it’s proof of the universality and uniformity of the fall. It’s why history keeps repeating itself. At any rate, the Opinion Police now have the upper hand which they use to bully and intimidate, and it’s not going away. In fact, it’s gaining traction. Thanks to technology, anyone, and I mean anyone -- any extremist or ignoramus -- can with a single click activate the Opinion Police. More proof of the universality and uniformity of the fall. Every human advance turns on itself.
Yes, it’s disturbing. A few weeks ago, the Opinion Police crossed the line with me. They denounced Paw Patrol with threatening demands that it be cancelled. Now I happen to be an expert on Paw Patrol. It came out soon after I adopted Herry. It’s common for foreign adopted children to cling to a certain TV shows as they acquire a new language that instinct teaches them they need to learn to survive. Herry clung to Paw Patrol. And I mean, Herry clung to Paw Patrol. Then just as he weaned himself of it, I adopted Adam. Adam clung to Paw Patrol. So, year after year, I have been watching Paw Patrol. I have seen an embarrassing number of episodes, some half a dozen times. It may actually be possible that I have seen more Paw Patrol episodes than any adult on the planet.
In case you’ve not had the pleasure, Paw Patrol it’s about a ten year old boy named Ryder. Ryder leads a band of puppies. There’s Marshall, a Dalmatian, who is a fire fighter; Rubble, a Bulldog, whose works construction; Chase, a German Shepherd, who is a police officer; Zumba, a Labrador, who mans the seas, and Skye, a Cockapoo, who mans the skies. Together, they form a team of rescuers. That’s the long and short of it. They rescue things -- things like baby sea turtles. It has no further agenda but to extol rescuers to children. It wants children to understand the goodness and importance of rescuers.
And it’s amazing really -- so many things right under our nose are amazing --that there are rescuers out there - people out there who devote their lives, often at great risk and sacrifice, to saving people who are in danger. It proves that despite the fall, there’s good in us yet. But the Opinion Police do not believe in the reality
of rescuers much less their goodness and importance.
Our morning’s gospel lesson speaks of the sin against the Holy Spirit, the eternal sin that can never be forgiven. Scholars puzzle over exactly what this sin is. I think I know. It’s when moral blindness becomes total, so that the bad becomes the good, and the good becomes the bad -- like in Nazi Germany. The Nazis advanced that it was good to gas Jewish women and children. They were enemies of the state.
And the reason it can never be forgiven is that it can’t be acknowledged so it can’t be repented. It’s worth being reminded that sin must be repented before it is forgiven, at least according to Jesus. We sometimes get the convenient idea that forgiveness is automatic. That no matter how refractory and recalcitrant we are, we are automatically forgiven. Well it’s not the case. Sin must be repented before it is forgiven.
Now you might think that the condemnation of Paw Patrol is a rather venial example to summon the sin against the Holy Spirit, the eternal sin that can never be forgiven. I don’t think so. Rescuers are now under attack. Our children are not to be taught that they are worthy, not to be taught that it is worthy to save people who are in danger. That’s a complete inversion of bad and good.
But this more than my opinion. It is the opinion of the Bible. Look at Abraham who rescued Lot from foreign captivity. Look at Moses who rescued the people of Israel from Egyptian slavery. Look at David who rescued Abigail from an abusive husband. Look at Esther who rescued the Jewish people from annihilation. Look at Ruth who rescued her mother-in-law from grief and bitterness. Look at the Good Samaritan, and look good and hard at him, because he rescued his enemy and in so doing made him his neighbor.
Above all, look at Jesus Christ. He rescued humankind from sin and in so doing reconciled humankind to God. Existence would indeed be troubled and troubling if not for that, if all we had was this existence and nothing more. No God. No truth. No eternity. No heaven. No hope.
The Opinion Police then must not drive us not to capitulation, to the preemption of our opinions with theirs. They should drive us rather to scrutinize our opinions. They should drive us to evaluate our opinions. They should drive us to test our opinions. They should drive us to allow others, in a common aim for what’s right, to test our opinions. They should drive us to defend our opinions. They should drive us to enact our opinions. Because Moynihan is right -- everyone is entitled to his opinion. But we can appeal to a mind far greater Moynihan’s. We can appeal to Martin Luther, the founder of our Reformed Tradition, who as the bedrock of that tradition asserted and demanded the conscience of the individual believer.
Friends, we live in troubled and troubling times. Let us not just pray for rescuers, but let us ourselves be rescuers. Amen.