According to the Bible, there are two types of sinners out there: those who are resourceful enough to appear respectable, and those who are not.
The Pharisees belonged to the former type – those who are resourceful enough to appear respectable. The very word Pharisee is suggestive of this. Pharisee means “set apart” – “set apart” – as in “a cut above”, as in a “upper crust”, as in “first string.” And why were the Pharisees “set apart” in this elite way? It was because they had separated themselves from the general run of humanity to devote themselves to the Law of Moses and devote themselves to the Law of Moses they did. They devoted themselves to its every letter, and that’s a lot of letters – 10 Commandments and 613 more supplementary statutes. And not only this, they had adapted the Law of Moses to address the needs of their day by promulgating more statutes – thousands and thousands of them. And naturally, their dress reflected their identity. After all, the dress of police officers reflects their identity, and football players, and ballerinas. So it was with the Pharisees. They arrayed themselves in fine robes. They wore “their fringes long and their phylacteries broad,” as Jesus himself described it. And too, Jesus described how they put great stock in being given the place of honor at the banquet, and the best seats at the synagogue, and to be greeted with respect in the marketplace. Yes, in every way the Pharisees belonged to the type of sinners resourceful enough to appear respectable.
Tax Collectors belonged to the latter type of sinners, those not resourceful enough to appear respectable. Tax collectors were stationed along toll roads in toll booths, in much the same way tax collectors are stationed today along toll roads in toll booths, but they were not nearly as innocuous as today’s tax collectors. They collected taxes for the Roman Empire, which had built toll roads throughout its extensive territory. Tax collectors then held disreputable positions for two reasons. Number one, they profited off the Roman Empire, in other words, they profited off the enemy. And number two, they worked on commission, and this often tempted them in the direction of extortion.
Of course, a case could be made for these tax collectors. It’s easy enough cast judgment against someone who earns their living in a disreputable way, we who have been privileged to avoid that fate. But what lengths would you go if you had to feed your children and put a roof over their heads? Personally, I would do just about anything, reputable or not. People who are up against it can’t always afford reputable positions.
At any rate, there is a curious, or maybe not so curious, phenomenon about these two types of sinners. It is this: Those who are resourceful enough to appear respectable tend to look down, and I mean way down, upon those who are not resourceful enough to appear respectable.
Consider this morning’s gospel lesson. As Jesus walked along, he encountered a Tax Collector named Matthew sitting in a toll booth. Jesus called him to discipleship. It was a bit of a surprising choice, precisely because Tax Collectors held disreputable positions. Jesus had thus far called four disciples, and they had all been fishermen. That was not exactly a prestigious position, but there was nothing disreputable about it. And even more surprising was that Jesus had dinner that evening with Matthew and his “ilk” -- as our gospel lesson puts it, “with many Tax Collectors and sinners.” Who these other sinners were exactly is impossible to pinpoint, but we can assume from the kinds of people Jesus gravitated toward – prostitutes, lepers, and the like -- they were more of the same. The Pharisees were utterly disgusted by it. They looked down upon Tax Collectors and sinners, and they judged that Jesus should too. They approached Jesus’ disciples, demanding, “Why does your teacher eat with Tax Collectors and sinners?”
But of course, Jesus was all over the phenomenon that those sinners who are resourceful enough to appear respectable look down upon those sinners who are not resourceful enough to appear respectable. And so he turned the tables on the Pharisees, “Go see what it means that God desires mercy,” he retorted. For all your “respectability,” Jesus was saying, for your lack of mercy, you are no better than they, and they are no worse than you.
The type of sinners who are not resourceful enough to appear respectable are no worse than those who are. It is precisely here that Jesus imparts an essential lesson for his day and for ours, a lesson that sounds as good news to the type of sinners not resourceful enough to appear respectable -- good news because it comes as news in the first place. For as often as not, the type of sinners not resourceful enough to appear respectable are their own worst enemies. They accept that those who are resourceful enough to appear respectable look down upon them. They accept that definition of themselves. And so they order themselves below “respectable” society and relegate themselves to the margins. There they subsist banded together and living life on the defensive. They come not to expect much from life or from themselves. And the upshot of all this is that their lives are diminished, and life in general is diminished for it never receives all they might have offered.
Yes, they accept that definition of themselves, but no one less than Jesus Christ declared that they should not. They should, rather, accept his definition of them, and his definition is that they are no worse than anyone else. More so, Jesus Christ declared they are more likely to recognize their need for him, more likely to seek him, more likely to be healed by the Great Physician because it has been made so amply known to them that that are ill and need his care. And it is just such as these, Jesus Christ declared, who will inherit the Kingdom of God.
So, you’ve earned a reputation that you’ll never live down. You’re no worse than anyone else. So you’ve made some mistakes, and bad ones, costly ones. You’re no worse than anyone else. So your spouse left you, you’re no worse than anyone else. So you can’t begin to keep up with the Jones’ – your standard of living will never be near to those around you. You’re no worse than anyone else. So your mother or father brought disgrace upon the family, you’re no worse than anyone else. So you’re battling an addiction, so you have a communicable disease, so you’re living paycheck to paycheck and your credit score is hovering around 300, so your children can’t keep up, so you a member of one of the groups that society stigmatizes, so your life reads like more of a horror story than a storybook, by the declaration of Jesus Christ, you are no worse than anyone else. Don’t let it hold you back, and especially don’t let it hold you back from the Kingdom of God. Jesus Christ declared you will inherit it.
The apostle Paul, of course, once belonged to that former type, once belonged to the type of sinners resourceful enough to appear respectable. He was a Pharisee, after all. a Pharisee who out-Phariseed the Pharisees; that is, until Jesus Christ knocked him off his high horse. It was then Jesus Christ taught him what he teaches us here today – That true respectability begins in the faith that Jesus Christ has justified all sinners on his cross. Amen.