Certainly the account of the Sacrifice of Isaac, which records God’s demand for the sacrifice of Abraham’s beloved son and long awaited heir, is one of the most difficult and troubling accounts in the entire Bible.
Earlier in the narrative, the text tells us, Abraham had answered the call of a previously unknown God. Prior to God’s call and Abraham’s answer, there had been no history between God and humankind. The God who was to become the God of Israel and the father of Jesus Christ was, in his call to Abraham, just introducing himself. Prior to that introduction, Abraham was but an undistinguished, semi-nomadic herdsman meting out his living in Mesopotamia. His religion could only have been paganism, since paganism was the only religion that existed.
Then seemingly out of no where, God called to Abraham – “Go from your country and your kindred…Go from you father’s house to the land that I will show you…I will make of you a great nation….I will bless you and make your name great…Your descendants shall be like the stars in the sky….” Hence began the covenant between God and Israel that culminated in the birth, death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ.
Abraham’s righteousness, the text tells us, was his faith in this unknown God, faith that, despite appearances, despite odds, this unknown God would make good on his promises – His promises of land, of nationhood, and of a son and heir.
And it must be recalled and underscored that this was a heretofore unknown God. Abraham’s faith is made all the more remarkable by this fact. We today take for granted that we are the inheritors of an ancient and enduring tradition that bolsters and fortifies our faith. We as Christians owe a great debt for the strength of our faith to our Christian forbears, the keepers of the tradition, the clouds of witness – people like the apostle Paul, Augustine of Hippo, Martin Luther, Abraham Lincoln, Martin Luther King, Jr., Mother Teresa, Desmond Tutu, etc., etc., etc. We owe a great debt to the strength of our faith to our culture that is shaped by and still, despite the ravages of
post-modernity, adheres to Judeo-Christian assumptions and values. But Abraham did not inherit any tradition. He had only the call of an unknown God. Yet he believed, and “his faith was reckoned to him as righteousness.”
As a down payment to Abraham that this unknown God made good on his promises, Abraham and Sarah received their long awaited son and heir, whom, the text tells us, they loved very dearly. And then this unknown God commanded of the faithful Abraham the unthinkable -- the sacrifice of Isaac – a command that shattered all rationality and all moral order. And if the command itself was not horrific enough, it represented the abrupt severance of all God’s promises to Abraham. For the promises did not rest just with Abraham. The promises depended upon his heir for their fruition. In this horrific command God added insult to injury by appearing to renege on his promises.
So what are we to make of all this?
For one thing, the account of the Sacrifice of Isaac contains a certain, albeit inferred recognition. It is the recognition that there is an uncompromising
codicil attached to each and every event of human and cosmic history – namely, that God will not be justified by human beings. God’s ways are GOD’S ways, and they often make absolutely no sense to us. This is why even a life of faith is still a life with no guarantees. God who has revealed himself to us as a God of love, justice, and mercy; his love, justice, and mercy notwithstanding, can and does permit the events of life to fall upon people, the righteous and unrighteous alike, with a force that can crush all calculations and hopes under burdens so unbearable that one can hardly endure the thought of going on with God.
Had Abraham become a so-called “protest atheist” upon hearing God’s command to sacrifice Isaac, that we could understand, but what is bewildering and miraculous about Abraham and all others who live by faith in this strange and confounding world of ours, is that they carry on with God. In the face of episodes of inexplicable suffering, tragedy, and moral disorder, they carry on with God, hoping against hope that God will not require more than they can endure, but knowing that he may indeed require more than they can endure. The faithful carry on with God in faith that God knows what he is doing, that he is not arbitrary or cruel or capricious or powerless or nonexistent, but that he is a righteous God. This faith, this faith that come what may carries on with God; this is the faith of Abraham.
I have spoken before of my father’s death from cancer. Near the onset of that cancer, I was privileged to witness the faith of Abraham. My father’s diagnosis was dire, and his prognosis was not hopeful. We did what many other families have done. We made a pilgrimage to the Mayo Clinic. My stay there made a deep, ineffaceable impression upon me. My father was on a ward with people who were very very sick. Suffering and death hung over the place – it was palpable. But in that grave place there was an air I had never breathed before or since. All the wall that we humans so pridefully erect and that divide us – walls of race, walls of class – were torn down. Human pretensions and conceits were recognized on that ward for the trivial tings that they are; because fear, tragedy, loss, and death are great equalizers. But coupled there with the deep sorrow was deep compassion and empathy; coupled with fear was hope; coupled with tragedy beyond explanation was faith.
And when many of us came together for worship on Sunday – and the snapshots are still vivid in my memory – sick children comforting weeping parents; two young women who were twins – one hale and healthy, one ashen and bald from chemotherapy; doctors and nurses in large numbers worshiping and praying with those they south to heal – the faith in that place witnessed to the faith of Abraham, the faith that come what may carries on with God.
Of course, not all life in faith is lived is desperate crisis and disorder. It is often the case that we can exercise a certain control over our destinies by living upright lives. Lives of moderation, hard work, justice, and decency often find positive responses in the world, and those exhibiting such attributes prosper. As well they should. Life with God can be like a long comfortable marriage.
But sometimes, with Abraham, we are delivered into realms so foreign to our standards of justice, so offensive to our morality, that our explanations fall to pieces, and this is where we may and we must look to Abraham as a model for our faith.
But there is yet more to Abraham’s faith, more than the fact that it perdures. There is yet the very key to it. They is yet the reason why it perdures. It does not perdure because it is stupid or stubborn. It does not perdure because it is irrational or blind. Abraham’s faith in the ultimate righteousness of the God who commanded such a thing as the sacrifice of Isaac would be utterly incomprehensible if Abraham’s faith was not given to know that some how, some where, some way, some time God would vindicate the terrible justice of his ways.
The intervention of God’s angel only deferred the larger question, for not only do angels not always intervene, but Isaac someday had to die. All finite life in this cosmos will be sacrificed in fulfillment of God’s order.
But there inhered in Abraham’s faith – as one of its properties, in its quality, of its essence, the knowledge that the way of God’s righteousness will not remain forever opaque, and when the way of his righteousness is ultimately revealed, our faith in him will have been justified.
It is here that Abraham, without prophet, without Christ, and without tradition, stood at the brink of the mystery. It is here that faith inspired him to know what Christ’s resurrection would proclaim some 1900 years later – that faith is given to look forward to God’s ultimate redemption and salvation. Amen.