It is said that laughter makes the world go round, and there is much truth in these words. They refer, I think, to the kind of laughter that celebrates the sheer joy of existence in all its manifold array –the mystery and vastness of the cosmos: nature’s beauty and grandeur; human achievements like music, art, and science; human institutions like family, community, and nation. Holidays, babies, candy stores, parades, rainbows, make-believe….the whole lot of it. And this kind of laughter rightly celebrates the sheer joy of existence in all its manifold array. After all, God created it and called it good. This kind of laughter thanks and praises him for it. That must be why it seems to make the world go around.
It is said too that laughter is the best medicine, and there is too much truth in these words. They refer to the kind of laughter that acknowledges our foibles – our personality flaws, our self-importance -- most of all our taking ourselves so seriously. It is a needful acknowledgment of them, but mostly it is a kindly acknowledgement of them, a forgiving acknowledgment, an acknowledgment that sees ridiculousness for ridiculousness and give it its due. That must be why it is such good medicine.
But there are many kinds of laughter, and not all of them are salutary. There is the laughter that is coarse and unrestrained, even a little frightening; the laughter that gives expression to more of a grimace than a smile. It is often heard in bar rooms and like haunts. It is laughter born of an attempt to escape -- escape from thinking, escape from responsibility, escape from oneself. And if it’s loud enough and hard enough, one can about convinces oneself that this is really living.
There is the laughter that is used to mock or humiliate, laughter whose source and aim is cruelty. This kind of laughter, sad to say, children are often guilty of, and for reasons I have never been able to fathom, permitted by their parents and teachers to be guilty of. My son has long since forgotten it, but once when he was about seven he received a bow tie as a present from his grandfather who wears bow ties. He wore it to his Christmas pageant as school. He came home that day no longer wearing the bow tie and with red, swollen eyes. “What happened?” I asked him. “They all laughed at me,” he said.
And then there is the laughter of disbelief. This is the laughter of hope dashers and nay sayers, the laughter of cynics and conformists. Ira Gershwin wrote some of his best song lyrics about it. “They all laughed at Christopher Columbus when he said the world was round. They all laughed when Edison recorded sound. They all laughed at Milton and his steamboat, Hershey and his chocolate bar. They told Marconi, wireless was a phony, it’s the same old cry.”
This laughter of disbelief, I fear, was Abraham and Sarah’s laughter. God first appeared to Abraham and commanded him to journey to a faraway land that the nation he would someday father would occupy. Abraham obeyed God’s command, but nothing came of it. Many uneventful years passed in that faraway land. And time was not on his side, because Abraham and Sarah were getting on in years, and they as yet had no offspring. How was he to father a nation with no offspring? Then after twenty five years, the Lord appeared to Abraham again, to announce that his offspring was soon to be born. But perhaps because it was after twenty five years, for by this time Abraham was an old man, he merely fell on his face and laughed.
Next it was Sarah’s turn to laugh, as we heard in this morning’s Old Testament lesson. The Lord soon thereafter appeared to Abraham again in the form of three men in order to waylay his disbelief. “I will surely return to you in due season, and your wife Sarah shall have a son.” But Sarah, who was eavesdropping, too laughed. Both of them laughed the laughter of disbelief – the laughter of the hope dashers of nay sayers, the laughter of conformists and cynics.
But perhaps this is to be too hard on them. Perhaps this is not quite on the mark. Perhaps there is another kind of laughter of disbelief. Because if you think about it, belief, particularly belief in someone demands great vulnerability. Believe in someone and you can be disappointed. Believe in someone, and you can be hurt. Believe in someone, and you can be betrayed. Believe in someone, and you can be humiliated. So perhaps deep down Abraham and Sarah wanted desperately to believe, but they were afraid to take the chance. They were afraid to risk it. So they laughed to protect themselves. They laughed against their deep want to believe as if to say you can’t fool me. We are more familiar with this kind of laughter than we might be aware. It is, I believe, nothing less than emblematic of the position to which our times have driven us.
We live in times in which belief has about been superseded. By what I’m not sure; it seems a lot of default ignorance and confusion, but the evidence against belief is overwhelming and continues to mount. There is the rise of science, which offers a plausible and reasonable explanation for reality, one that seems to those unsure of biblical interpretation to stand over against the Bible, to cast it in error. And then there are all the nineteenth and twentieth century philosophers and ideologues who in one way or another have all pronounced God dead. And then there are the two world wars of the twentieth century that have raised the problem of evil in such a way that it can no longer be ignored or neglected. God is all good and all powerful? Tell that to the boys in the trenches. Tell that to the Jews in the extermination camps. And then there is popular culture that shuns God altogether, that takes his name as either a curse word or a social gaffe. Then there is globalization that has opened our eyes to the world religions, worthy enough belief systems. So what makes us think ours is true, and not just a relative cultural expression of religion?
All of this has carried us and continues to carry us farther and farther away from belief. But on the other hand, it has not quite won us over. Every so often we glance back over our shoulders to see if we have really become unmoored from belief -- from God and the whole of the Christian tradition -- if we are really now just adrift. And we do not feel delighted to be free of it. We feel sad to see it go, and we are frightened.
And then there are stirrings in our hearts when we think of Jesus himself. There remains something so true about him. He seems to make whole and complete all the fragments of our experience. And too there are deeper stirrings in our hearts that tell us we still want and need a lord and savior, that we still hope all of his promises to us are true – that we are forgiven and loved, that our loved ones are forgiven and loved, that we will some day know all suffering and injustice to have been a temporary affliction.
But on the other hand, we live in times in which belief has been about superseded and the case against it is strong. And so we too laugh in disbelief, not wanting to look and feel credulous, but at the same time, inwardly hoping against hope.
But we must not forget how the story of Abraham and Sarah ends, for in fact their laughter of disbelief is meant to teach us that our laughter of disbelief is unfounded, because at the birth of Isaac Abraham and Sarah laugh once again -- the most sublime and profound laughter of all, the laughter that rejoices in the certainty of belief. It is meant to teach us that that is the laughter to which our laughter of disbelief will always and inevitably give way. Amen.