I am a big fan of the teachable moment. For those of you who might have heard that expression but can’t quite name what it is, a teachable moment is when a spontaneous occasion arises for you to teach -- to offer your expertise or experience. The key word here is spontaneous.
As a teacher, a teachable moment occurs when I am delivering a routine lecture, and someone asks a question. This allows me to apply the material in a fresh way that is relevant to the questioner. As a parent, a teachable moment occurs for me about a hundred times a day. This is because kids have so very much to learn on so very many levels. Teachable moments are an ad hoc kind of way to teach, but some of the best teaching takes place in teachable moments. I think it’s precisely because they are spontaneous. They’re live. They’re real life.
Jesus, in this morning’s gospel lesson, had a teachable moment -- at least he thought he did. A massive crowd had followed him into the middle of nowhere. Jesus had gone to the middle of nowhere to get away from it all. But the crowd heard he had been performing miracles, and they wanted to witness one. But getting to the middle of nowhere took some time, and by the time the crowd got there, they were tired, but particularly they were hungry. They had wanted to witness a miracle, and they were about to. Jesus canvassed the crowd for what food they had. It was not much -- two fish and five loaves of bread. Jesus multiplied them so that the entire crowd was amply fed with leftovers to spare. That got their attention.
Jesus then again tried to get away from it all, but it was not to be. By the next morning, the crowd caught up with him. They wanted to see that miracle repeated. But this time it was not so much for the sake of witnessing a miracle, but because the miracle filled their bellies. They saw Jesus as their meal ticket. “You’ve got it all wrong,” Jesus told them, and he attempted to clarify. “I am more than a meal ticket. The miracle got your attention. That’s why I performed it -- so that I have your attention when I impart to you the fullness of it, when I impart to you that I am God’s gift to you of divine life for all eternity.”
The crowd was flabbergasted, flabbergasted as well as skeptical, if not to say chagrined. “Just who are you claiming to be?” The crowd demanded. “Moses himself, the founder of the faith, fed his people bread miraculously. Remember manna, Jesus? So you are saying you are greater than Moses?” Here it was. His teachable moment. “So you are saying you are greater than Moses?”
“Yes, exactly! Yes, precisely! That’s what I am saying. Yes, and yes again. That’s it. Moses fed his people bread miraculously. He satisfied their physical hunger. But still they died. I am greater than Moses. I have come not merely to satisfy your physical hunger. I have come to awaken in you a spiritual hunger, a hunger for God’s gift of divine life for all eternity which I and I alone can give you. You must believe that I am the Bread of Life!”
Unfortunately, his teachable moment did not go so well. Their response has to be the lamest responses in human history. “Oh yeah?” They retorted. “Well we happen to know where you came from. We know you are Joseph’s son from Nazareth.” Joseph was some random carpenter. Nazareth was in the boondocks.
Yes, this is as lame as it gets. For one thing, it’s wrong -- demonstrably and empirically wrong. Great men (and women) emerge out of nowhere. There are no predictors for great men and women, none, whatsoever. Not place. Not time. Not lineage. Not gender. Not race. Not wealth. Not education. Great men and women just emerge. Abraham. Moses. David. Amos. Ruth. Mary. Paul. Or closer to home Abraham Lincoln, Winston Churchill, Harriet Tubman, Martin Luther King, Jr., young Malala who I mentioned a couple weeks ago. You could probably name a few. They all just emerged.
But beyond that there is an insidious prejudice lurking that unless you have the right zip code, the right era, the right family, the right sex, the right color, the right net worth, the right degree, you’ll never amount to anything. So his teachable moment was lost to lameness, lameness in the extreme.
It makes you wonder just why his teachable moment failed so miserably? Didn’t he at least deserve the benefit of the doubt? I mean, he did just multiply those loaves and fishes. And 5,000 people means a lot of multiplication. And prior to that he healed a paralyzed man, paralyzed for nearly forty years. And prior to that he healed a boy who was more dead than alive. And prior to that he turned water into wine.
They had nothing to lose, after all. His offer was not exactly shabby - divine life for all eternity. Not too bad an offer in the face of all the ravages of sin which play out under the specter of death. They had nothing to lose, they just had to believe. But they refused. They shut him down because of where he came from. It’s inexplicable really.
Friends, his teachable moment still stands. It is now offered to us. He speaks to us across the centuries. “I care about your physical needs. I care deeply. This is why I fed you. This is why I healed you. This is why I rescued you from death. I care about your physical needs. But there is more than the physical. There is the spiritual. And this is my ultimate care. I can bestow upon you spiritual life, divine life, in the here and now and in the great hereafter. Because I am greater than Moses. I am greater than any man. I am the Bread of Life. Believe in me.”
How will his teachable moment go with us? Will it go any better, or will we refuse his offer? Will we shut him down? Of course, we can’t do so using their response - We know where you came from. That’s already been exposed for its lameness. But there are other forms of lameness. How about this one?
“You and that musty old book full of myths and miracles. It’s so passe we wouldn’t even bother to open it. We have a better offer than yours, and one much more up to date. We have high tech distractions. We have laptops and smartphones. We have netflix and amazon prime. We have facebook and instagram. We have world travel and even space travel.” How will his teachable moment go with us? Will it be lost to our own forms of lameness?
Blaise Pascal was one of my heroes. He was a great man who, parenthetically, emerged out of nowhere. He was home schooled by his father who was a tax collector. He turned out to be one of the greatest geniuses in human history. He was a brilliant and groundbreaking Mathematician and Physicist, but he is best known as a theologian. He never intended to be a theologian. God intended him to be a theologian. Like Paul and Augustine, he had a dramatic conversion experience. At any rate, as a theologian, he developed what came to be known as Pascal’s wager. His wager stated that it is only rational to wager that God exists. If he does not, you’ve lost nothing, doubtless lived a more moral and upright life that accomplished some good. But if you wager God does not exist, and he does, you’ve lost everything. Let Pascal’s wager be our own. As Christ implores us, “Do not doubt but believe.” Amen.